The novel is enjoyable but not remarkable, falling into the category of books that are pleasant to read but don't leave a lasting impact.
This reviewer found 'A Spool of Blue Thread' to be a pleasant read, but not one that stands out in the literary landscape. They appreciate the storytelling and the exploration of family life, but feel that the novel lacks the depth or uniqueness to be considered remarkable. The reviewer acknowledges that it's a good book, but one that might not stay with the reader long after finishing it. They also note that the characters are well-developed and the narrative is engaging, but the overall impact is somewhat mild.
Quick quotes
Anne Tyler's novel about four families of the Whitshank family falls into the category of books I consider 'enjoyable but not remarkable'
It is pretty poignant, yes. In Abby's case, there's concern that she's losing her memory a bit anyway and then … So it's worth a read
Her writing shines the brightest in this book. The first chapter still hurts as much even on the second reread.