Good Dirt

Good Dirt cover
Good Books rating 4.25
Technical
  • ID: 512
  • Added: 2025-09-13
  • Updated: 2025-11-01
  • ISBN: 9780593358368
  • Publisher: Random House
  • Published: 2025-01-28
  • Formats: 29
  • Reviews: 3

Good Dirt follows Ebby Freeman, the daughter of an affluent Black family in New England, whose life is shattered by the unsolved murder of her brother Baz and the loss of a cherished family heirloom—a centuries-old stoneware jar brought north by an enslaved ancestor. As Ebby grapples with her high-profile breakup and flees to a quiet French village, she confronts the enduring impact of her family's history and the public's voyeuristic fascination with their tragedy. In this evocative and sweeping novel, Charmaine Wilkerson weaves together past and present to explore themes of family, trauma, identity, and freedom. Through Ebby's journey, the story reveals how the legacy of slavery and generational loss shapes the present, while the mysterious jar symbolizes both the weight of history and the possibility of a new future. Good Dirt is a richly layered, emotional epic that examines how the past informs our present and offers a powerful meditation on healing and resilience.

Reviews
Shelf Reflection · 2025-02-17
poignant 4.25

The story is a well-crafted exploration of grief, trauma, and the influence of family history on identity, with a poignant focus on the lasting impact of a childhood tragedy and the symbolic family heirloom.

The review delves into how the novel portrays the profound effects of a traumatic family event on the protagonist, Ebony, and her family, emphasizing the societal spotlight on them as one of the few Black families in a wealthy neighborhood. The symbolic jar, passed down through generations, serves as a powerful narrative device linking past and present struggles, while the plot’s unfolding in both Massachusetts and France adds layers of emotional and historical complexity that drive Ebony’s journey toward healing and understanding.


Quick quotes

    She feels always known as 'the little black girl who had survived a suburban tragedy.'

    Henry Pepper had shown the world that Ebony Freeman, try as she might, could not escape the mantle of misfortune that had settled over her.

    Stories that tell of perseverance, courage, bravery, love, skill, and hope.

Libro Fulltime · 2025-02-11
nuanced 4.20

This novel is seen as a step up from the author’s previous work, offering a nuanced portrayal of a Black middle-class family with deep historical roots and traditions, enriched by the symbolic significance of a family heirloom tied to slavery and resilience.

The reviewer appreciates how this book advances beyond the author’s debut by presenting a complex family narrative that mirrors the traditions and behaviors of established families, highlighting issues of race and class. The historical elements, particularly the story of the jar crafted by an enslaved potter, add depth and a sense of continuity to the family’s legacy, illuminating themes of courage, survival, and the ongoing impact of history on present identities.


Quick quotes

    This really felt like a step up from her last novel – which was already very good.

    An important member of the family is 'Old Mo', a jar made by an enslaved man, Mo, a potter, which has passed down through the generations.

    Skipping back and forth through the centuries, we learn organically about the master potters, forced labour making particular kinds of pottery.

Seattle Book Mama · 2025-01-10
engaging 4.30

The novel skillfully handles multiple perspectives and time periods, weaving a complex family saga that explores trauma, secrets, and historical legacy, ultimately delivering a richer and more compelling story than the author’s previous work.

This review highlights how the author, Charmaine Wilkerson, uses numerous points of view and shifts between different time periods to deepen the narrative, initially causing some skepticism but ultimately proving effective. The historical passages about the ancestors’ experiences with slavery are seen as essential for understanding the story’s urgency and depth, while the contemporary viewpoints add humor and emotional complexity, making the novel a well-rounded and engaging multigenerational saga.


Quick quotes

    As in her previous novel, Wilkerson packs so many points of view into the story that I eventually stop counting.

    Some points of view are urgently necessary to carry the plot forward; others, like that of the intended groom, Henry, are straight-up hilarious in places.

    These passages aren’t entertaining, but they are necessary to provide clarity and urgency.

Appears in Lists