They initially enjoyed the book for its familiar yet fresh elements, but felt it lost momentum and became predictable. The review notes that the pacing issues detracted from the overall experience.
At first, the reviewer from Cannonball Read found The Taking of Jake Livingston enjoyable, appreciating the mix of familiar and new elements that kept them engaged. However, as the story progressed, they felt it started to lose steam and became somewhat predictable. The pacing issues were a notable downside, making the reading experience less satisfying than it could have been. Despite this, they acknowledge that the book has its moments and could be appealing to fans of the genre.
Quick quotes
At first The Taking of Jake Livingston was enjoyable.
There was enough familiar to make it comfortable, but new enough to not be the same-old.
The pacing issues were a notable downside, making the reading experience less satisfying than it could have been.