The book is influenced by the Lost Cause narrative, which may affect its portrayal of historical events. The reviewer acknowledges the book's impact but notes its controversial undertones.
This reviewer discusses the book's influence by the Lost Cause narrative, which presents a controversial perspective on the Civil War. They acknowledge the book's impact and engaging storyline but also highlight the problematic undertones that may affect its portrayal of historical events. The reviewer suggests that readers should be aware of these elements when approaching the book. Despite the controversial aspects, the book is seen as a significant work in the genre of alternative history.
Quick quotes
Yeah, Guns of the South is absolutely influenced by the Lost Cause, regardless of whether Turtledove is actually a decent guy or not.
It's a significant work in the genre of alternative history.
The book's impact and engaging storyline are acknowledged, but the problematic undertones are noted.