The story is a mixed bag with some awesome horror elements and solid individual characters, but it tries to do too much at once.
The reviewer from SFFWorld describes 'Girl in the Creek' as a mixed bag, noting that while it has some truly awesome horror elements and well-developed individual characters, the story tries to do too much at once. This can make it a bit overwhelming at times, but the reviewer appreciates the creativity and the chilling moments that make the book stand out. The reviewer also praises the conclusion, which brings everything together in a satisfying way, despite the book's flaws.
Quick quotes
A mixed bag for me. Some awesome horror/creepy elements, solid individual characters.
The story tries to do too many things at once with too many characters.
Where Wagner concludes the story… thumbs up.