Despite its flaws, the book is considered a candidate for the great American novel. The reviewer acknowledges its imperfections but still finds it compelling.
Bluestocking's review of 'Jitterbug Perfume' is a mix of criticism and admiration. They openly acknowledge that the book is flawed in ways that many readers might not find redeemable. However, despite these flaws, they still consider it a strong contender for the title of the great American novel. This duality in their review suggests a deep appreciation for the book's strengths, which outweigh its weaknesses in their eyes. Bluestocking's perspective highlights the book's unique qualities and its ability to leave a lasting impact, even if it's not a perfect read. They find the narrative and characters compelling enough to overlook its shortcomings, making it a memorable and significant work.
Quick quotes
I think this is still my personal candidate for great American novel.
This book is absolutely flawed, in ways many will not find redeemable.
It's not even something I'd necessarily recommend.