American Fire explores the arson spree in Accomack County, Virginia, through the lens of the troubled relationship between Tonya Bundick and Charlie Smith. The book delves into the economic and social decay of rural America, but leaves some deeper questions unanswered.
American Fire by Monica Hesse is a gripping account of the 67 arsons committed by Tonya Bundick and Charlie Smith in Accomack County, Virginia. The book meticulously traces the couple's relationship, from their initial romance to their descent into crime, set against the backdrop of a declining rural community. Hesse's detailed reporting brings to life the desperation and hopelessness that permeate the region, but the narrative falls short of fully exploring the underlying reasons behind Bundick's actions. The story is compelling, but the lack of deeper insight into the characters' motivations leaves readers wanting more. The book also highlights the stark contrast between the outsiders who observe the tragedy and the locals who live it, offering a poignant commentary on the divide between different worlds.
Quick quotes
The beginnings of fires were always filled with adrenaline and anticipation. The ends of them were soot and weariness and fire hoses that needed to be cleaned.
A feat of reportage doesn’t make a claim to be compassionate. And yet I found myself wishing for the kind of insight compassion brings.
The ultimate gift of nonfiction is to share what the writer thinks and feels. But Hesse never fully grapples with how much of the tragedy is rooted in this place.