Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery

by Robert Kolker
Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery cover
Good Books rating 4.43
True Crime
Technical:
  • ID: 881
  • Added: 2025-09-21
  • Updated: 2025-09-21
  • ISBN: 9780062183675
  • Publisher: Harper Collins
  • Published: 2013-07-09
  • Reviews: 3

Lost Girls delves into the tragic lives and presumed serial killings of five women whose bodies were discovered on Gilgo Beach, Long Island. Each woman had advertised on Craigslist and shared similar profiles, leading authorities to suspect a single killer. The book goes beyond the surface to explore the socioeconomic factors that led these women to their fate, offering a profound look at the overlooked struggles of rural America. Through extensive research and interviews with the victims' families, Robert Kolker paints a heartbreaking portrait of crime and circumstance that resonates with the broader issues of modern society.

Reviews
Here's the Fucking Twist · 2019-07-19
moving 4.50

The book is praised for its humanizing approach to the victims and its gripping narrative. The reviewer appreciates the investigative depth and emotional resonance.

This review highlights how the book masterfully tells the stories of the victims, making their lives and losses tangible. The reviewer is captivated by the author's ability to weave together investigative journalism with a deeply empathetic narrative. They also note how the book's exploration of the shadowy world of online escort services adds a layer of complexity to the mystery. Overall, it's a moving and compelling read that stays with you long after the last page.

Quick quotes

    Award-winning investigative reporter Robert Kolker delivers a humanizing account of the true-life search for a serial killer still at large on Long Island.

    The book is a gripping narrative that keeps you on the edge of your seat.

    Kolker's empathetic approach to the victims' stories makes this more than just a crime book; it's a poignant tribute.

The Book Lovers Boudoir · 2015-10-07
touching 4.80

The book is described as deeply sad and moving, leaving a lasting emotional impact. The reviewer found it to be one of the most touching books they have ever read.

This reviewer was profoundly affected by the book, describing it as one of the saddest and most touching they've ever encountered. They mention crying several times while reading and feeling emotionally drained even after finishing it. The reviewer appreciates the raw emotional honesty and the way the book honors the lives of the victims. It's a powerful read that doesn't shy away from the heart-wrenching details, making it a memorable and impactful experience.

Quick quotes

    Lost Girls is one of the saddest, moving and most touching books I've ever read.

    I cried several times reading it and my eyes still feel damp.

    The book honors the lives of the victims in a way that is both respectful and deeply moving.

The New York Times · 2013-07-16
haunting 4.00

The book is noted for its well-made physical presentation and haunting cover image. The reviewer praises the author's ability to delve deeply into the lives of the victims.

The New York Times reviewer points out the high production quality of the book, with a crisp and haunting cover that sets the tone for the gripping content within. They appreciate how Robert Kolker delves into the lives of the victims, providing a detailed and riveting narrative that sheds light on the shadow world of escorts in the Internet age. The reviewer finds the book to be a triumph of reporting, offering a compelling and empathetic look at a complex and tragic story.

Quick quotes

    Robert Kolker's 'Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery' is, physically, a well-made book.

    Its cover image is crisp and haunting.

    Kolker presents the first detailed look at the shadow world of escorts in the Internet age.

Appears in Lists