Horowitz's novel is well-plotted but falls short in character development and intellectual depth. The story feels more like a children's book than a classic Holmes mystery.
While The House of Silk is well-plotted, it falls short in character development and intellectual depth. The characters feel un-Holmesian, and the story feels more like a children's book than a classic Holmes mystery. The novel is entertaining, but it's not likely to become a classic in its own right. If you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes, you might be disappointed by the lack of depth and complexity in the characters and plot. The House of Silk is a good read, but it's not likely to become a classic in its own right.
Quick quotes
Well-plotted, clichéd, intellectually vapid, and with utterly un-Holmesian characters
Horowitz's novel resembles a children's book that has been revised by PD James
The story feels more like a children's book than a classic Holmes mystery