The edition is praised for its insightful explanatory notes by ST Joshi. However, it is noted that it is not a complete collection of Lovecraft's best works.
The reviewer finds this edition of Lovecraft's stories to be excellent, particularly appreciating the insightful explanatory notes by ST Joshi. These notes provide valuable context and enhance the reading experience. However, the reviewer also points out that this collection is not comprehensive and does not include all of Lovecraft's best works. Despite this, the stories included are seen as a great introduction to Lovecraft's unique style and themes. The reviewer recommends this edition for both new and experienced readers of Lovecraft's work.
Quick quotes
Yes it's a great edition in my opinion.
The explanatory notes by ST Joshi are really insightful.
Obviously it isn't a complete collection and some of his best stories are missing.