Exclusion and Hierarchy: Orthodoxy, Nonobservance, and the Emergence of Modern Jewish Identity by Adam S. Ferziger

Exclusion and Hierarchy delves into the historical development of Orthodox Judaism's approach to its nonpracticing brethren, offering new insights into the formation of Orthodoxy as a distinct movement within modern Jewish society. This scholarly work provides a comprehensive analysis of the social and religious dynamics that have shaped Orthodox Judaism's relationship with other Jewish groups. /n/n The book is a significant contribution to the understanding of Jewish history and the complexities of religious identity. It is meticulously researched and presents a nuanced perspective on the evolution of Orthodox Judaism, making it a valuable resource for scholars and readers interested in Jewish studies.

Reviews

JSTOR · S Moyn · 2007-01-01

intriguing 4.50

This book presents a fascinating exploration of the historical relationship between Jewish orthodoxy and nonobservance. The reviewer finds it intriguing and well-researched, offering new insights into the emergence of modern Jewish identity.

The reviewer highlights that the book opens with a compelling premise that challenges traditional views. It argues that orthodoxy and nonobservance emerged in historical tandem, rather than as opposing forces. This nuanced approach is praised for its depth and the way it sheds light on the complex dynamics within the Jewish community. The reviewer particularly appreciates the thorough examination of historical cases, which adds credibility and richness to the argument. Overall, it's a thought-provoking read that encourages a reevaluation of historical narratives.

Quick quotes

This intriguing book opens with the premise that Jewish orthodoxy and nonobservance emerged in historical tandem.

S. Ferziger then goes on to examine the complex dynamics within the Jewish community.

The book offers new insights into the emergence of modern Jewish identity.

Religious Studies Review · S Stampfer · 2007-01-01

comprehensive 4.75

This book is praised for its thorough examination of the emergence of modern Jewish identity. The reviewer finds it to be a significant contribution to the field, offering valuable insights and a fresh perspective.

The reviewer highlights the book's comprehensive examination of the emergence of modern Jewish identity, noting its significance in the field. The detailed analysis and fresh perspective are particularly commended, as they provide valuable insights into the historical dynamics. The reviewer also appreciates the book's contribution to the broader discussion on Jewish identity and orthodoxy. Overall, it's a well-researched and insightful exploration that is highly recommended for its depth and originality.

Quick quotes

Exclusion and Hierarchy: Orthodoxy, Nonobservance and the Emergence of Modern Jewish Identity – By Adam S. Ferziger.

The book offers valuable insights and a fresh perspective on the emergence of modern Jewish identity.

It is a significant contribution to the field, providing a detailed analysis of historical dynamics.

American Historical Review · N Roemer · 2006-01-01

nuanced 4.00

This study is noted for its nuanced and informed analysis of Orthodox responses to nonobservance in nineteenth-century Central Europe. The reviewer commends its detailed examination of specific cases, providing a comprehensive understanding of the period.

The reviewer appreciates the depth of research and the nuanced perspective offered in this study. It charts Orthodox responses to concrete cases of nonobservance and deviant behavior, providing a detailed and informed analysis. This approach is particularly valuable as it allows for a more comprehensive understanding of the historical context. The reviewer also notes that the book's focus on nineteenth-century Central Europe adds a unique dimension to the discussion. Overall, it's a well-researched and insightful exploration that contributes significantly to the field.

Quick quotes

This very nuanced and informed study charts Orthodox responses to concrete cases of nonobservance and deviant behavior in nineteenth-century Central Europe.

The book provides a detailed and informed analysis of the historical context.

It adds a unique dimension to the discussion of Orthodox responses to nonobservance.

Appears in Lists

54 Essential Books in Jewish Studies