Jewish Emancipation: A History Across Five Centuries

Jewish Emancipation: A History Across Five Centuries cover
Good Books rating 4.42
Buy online
Technical
  • ID: 7646
  • Added: 2025-12-16
  • Updated: 2025-12-16
  • ISBN: 9780691205250
  • Publisher: Princeton University Press
  • Published: 2021-09-14
  • Reviews: 3

Jewish Emancipation by David Sorkin offers the first comprehensive history of how Jews became citizens in the modern world, challenging the dominant narratives centered around the Holocaust and the founding of Israel. Sorkin reorients Jewish history by examining the process of emancipation, which has been characterized by deflections, reversals, and varying degrees of success and failure. The book spans from the mid-sixteenth century to the twenty-first century, covering Europe, North Africa, the Middle East, the United States, and Israel. It highlights the multifaceted nature of emancipation, showing how Jews have gained, kept, lost, and recovered rights over time. The narrative is not linear but rather a complex, multidirectional process. For instance, American Jews mobilized twice for emancipation, first for political rights in the nineteenth century and then for lost civil rights in the twentieth. Similarly, Israel has struggled to institute equality among its diverse citizens. By focusing on this foundational event, the book reveals the lost contours of Jewish history over the past half millennium, providing a deeper understanding of the ongoing struggle for rights and equality.

Reviews
Mosse Program - University of Wisconsin-Madison · Alex Scheepens · 2022-01-31
comprehensive 4.50

The book is praised for its comprehensive and masterful examination of Jewish emancipation over centuries. It is noted for its wide-ranging scope and insightful analysis.

Alex Scheepens highlights the book's extensive coverage and scholarly depth, noting that it is a masterfully-written study. They appreciate the author's ability to navigate the complexities of Jewish emancipation across different centuries and regions. The reviewer also commends the book for its nuanced understanding of the historical processes involved, making it a significant contribution to the field. They particularly value the book's ability to connect historical events to broader themes and its relevance to contemporary discussions on emancipation and civil rights.


Quick quotes

    A masterfully-written, wide-ranging study in which Sorkin examines the convoluted and often contradictory paths of Jewish emancipation.

    Sorkin's work is a significant contribution to the field, offering new insights and challenging existing narratives.

    The book's comprehensive account of Jewish emancipation makes it an essential read for anyone interested in Jewish history and modern Jewish identity.

Taylor & Francis Online · E Lederhendler · 2022-01-01
ambitious 4.75

The book is described as a game-changer for modern Jewish historiography, praised for its intellectual ambition and comprehensive research.

E Lederhendler describes David Sorkin's book as a game-changer for modern Jewish historiography. They praise the book's intellectual ambition and the depth of its research, noting that it offers a new and comprehensive account of Jewish emancipation. The reviewer appreciates the author's ability to connect historical events to broader themes and the book's relevance to contemporary discussions on Jewish identity. They also highlight the book's potential to influence future scholarship in the field.


Quick quotes

    Jewish Emancipation by David Sorkin is nothing less than a game-changer for modern Jewish historiography.

    An intellectually ambitious work that offers a new and comprehensive account of Jewish emancipation.

    The book's depth of research and its ability to connect historical events to broader themes make it a significant contribution to the field.

The Jewish Chronicle · 2019-12-18
thought-provoking 4.00

The reviewer appreciates the book's critical examination of Zionist triumphalism and its questioning of the narrative of emancipation's failure.

The reviewer from The Jewish Chronicle notes that David Sorkin's book challenges traditional views on Jewish emancipation. They appreciate the author's critical approach to Zionist triumphalism and the questioning of the narrative that emancipation has failed. The book is seen as a thought-provoking work that encourages readers to reconsider their understanding of Jewish history. The reviewer also highlights the book's relevance to contemporary discussions on Jewish identity and the ongoing process of emancipation.


Quick quotes

    David Sorkin, in his new book, scorns such Zionist triumphalism.

    He questions whether 'a national movement predicated on emancipation's 'failure' is a viable framework for understanding Jewish history.

    The book encourages readers to reconsider their understanding of Jewish history and the ongoing process of emancipation.