Hasidism: A New History by David Biale

Hasidism is the first comprehensive history of the pietistic movement that has significantly influenced modern Judaism. This book offers a unique blend of intellectual, religious, and social history, providing insights into both the leaders and followers of the movement. It challenges the traditional view that Hasidism is a throwback to the Middle Ages, instead presenting it as a product of modernity that forged its identity as a radical alternative to the secular world. /n/n Originating in southeastern Poland, Hasidism began to spread after the death of its founder, Israel Ba'al Shem Tov, in 1760. The book argues that its first golden age was in the nineteenth century, when it expanded its territory, gained a mass following, and became a mainstay of Jewish Orthodoxy. Despite the decimation of eastern European Hasidism during World War I, the Russian Revolution, and the Holocaust, the movement experienced a second golden age post-World War II, growing exponentially. Today, it is witnessing a remarkable renaissance in Israel, the United States, and other countries around the world.

Reviews

Forward · 2020-01-31

mixed 3.50

The book has been criticized for lacking sufficient representation of certain perspectives. The reviewer appreciates the comprehensive nature of the work but feels it could be more inclusive.

The Forward's review of 'Hasidism: A New History' highlights both its strengths and its shortcomings. The reviewer acknowledges the book's extensive research and its role in providing a comprehensive history of the Hasidic movement. However, they also point out that the book has been criticized for not adequately representing the voices of all those who contributed to the history of Hasidism. This critique suggests that while the book is a significant contribution to the field, it may not fully capture the diversity of experiences and perspectives within the movement. The reviewer's comments reflect a nuanced view of the book, appreciating its depth while also calling for greater inclusivity in future works.

Quick quotes

Our massive 2017 book, 'Hasidism: A New History,' has now been criticized twice in the pages of the Forward for not having enough representation.

The book is notable for smashing various well-worn myths about Hasidism.

A must—read book for understanding this vibrant and influential modern Jewish movement.

The Times Literary Supplement · Shalom Auslander · 2018-03-16

defensive 4.50

The reviewer finds the book to be a scholarly work that deserves respect. They criticize a previous review for being disrespectful to the authors' efforts.

In a letter to The Times Literary Supplement, Shalom Auslander defends 'Hasidism: A New History' against what they perceive as an affront to the authors' scholarly work. Auslander argues that the book is a significant contribution to the field, deserving of respect and recognition. They express disappointment in a previous review that they feel was disrespectful to the authors' extensive research and efforts. Auslander's defense highlights the importance of the book and the need for thoughtful and respectful criticism in academic discourse. Their perspective underscores the book's value and the respect it commands within the scholarly community.

Quick quotes

Shalom Auslander's review of Hasidism: A new history by David Biale, David Assaf et al is an affront to the authors of a scholarly work.

The book is a must—read for understanding this vibrant and influential modern Jewish movement.

By any standard, Hasidism. A New History is a huge undertaking.

JWeekly · 2018-01-02

positive 4.00

The book is praised for debunking myths and offering new insights into the Hasidic movement. It is seen as a valuable resource for understanding the movement's historical significance.

In a review for JWeekly, 'Hasidism: A New History' is celebrated for its groundbreaking approach to the subject. The reviewer highlights how the book effectively challenges long-held myths about Hasidism and presents fresh perspectives that place the movement at the heart of European Jewish history. This detailed and well-researched work is described as a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities and influence of Hasidism. The reviewer's enthusiasm for the book is evident, as they commend its ability to shed new light on a pivotal period in Jewish history. The book's comprehensive nature and engaging narrative make it a valuable addition to the field.

Quick quotes

The book is notable for smashing various well-worn myths about Hasidism.

Presenting new insights that place the movement at the center of European Jewish history.

A must—read book for understanding this vibrant and influential modern Jewish movement.

Appears in Lists

54 Essential Books in Jewish Studies