The book is very good but has clear limitations. It's loved for its historical depth, but some aspects feel incomplete.
The reviewer appreciates the book's historical depth and the way it brings the Korean War to life. They highlight the author's ability to capture the nuances of the conflict and the political decisions that shaped it. However, they also note that the book has some limitations, particularly in its coverage of certain events and its pacing, which can feel uneven at times. Overall, it's a compelling read that offers valuable insights into a often overlooked war.
Quick quotes
Overall, The Coldest Winter is a very good book, but I also think it is a book with some very clear limitations.
I love it when history books bring the past to life in a way that feels immediate and relevant.
The book's strengths lie in its detailed narrative and its ability to capture the human dimension of the war.