The novel showcases Scott's imaginative storytelling and historical engagement but is criticized for its melodramatic elements and poetic license.
This review acknowledges Scott's talent for storytelling and his ability to engage with historical events. However, it also points out that the novel can be overly melodramatic at times, which might detract from the overall experience. The reviewer appreciates the poetic elements but feels they sometimes overshadow the historical accuracy and depth of the narrative.
Quick quotes
While 'Woodstock' showcases Scott's imaginative storytelling and historical engagement, it has also faced criticism for its melodramatic elements.
The poetic license taken in the novel adds a layer of complexity.
The historical context is rich but sometimes overshadowed by the melodrama.