Simon

by Rosemary Sutcliff
Simon cover
Good Books rating 4.23
Historical Fiction
Buy online
Amazon
Format/Price Check
Technical
  • ID: 6902
  • Added: 2025-12-05
  • Updated: 2025-12-05
  • ISBN: 9781448173143
  • Publisher: Random House
  • Published: 2013-11-30
  • Reviews: 3

Simon Carey and Amias Hannaford grew up as close friends, their political differences never seeming important. However, when the English Civil War erupts, they find themselves fighting on different sides, with Simon supporting Parliament and Amias siding with the royalists. The narrative explores the complexities of loyalty, friendship, and the personal cost of war. As the conflict intensifies, the two friends are forced to confront the true meaning of their bond and the choices they must make to survive. The story is a poignant exploration of the human condition set against the backdrop of one of England's most tumultuous periods.

Reviews
Susan's Bookshelves · Susan Elkin · 2025-12-05
engaging 4.20

Many of the characters in the book have a sense of 'otherness', which adds depth to the narrative. Simon's isolation is particularly poignant.

Susan Elkin points out that many of Rosemary Sutcliff's characters have a sense of 'otherness', whether they are alone or outcasts. In 'Simon', this theme is particularly evident as Simon feels cut off once the Civil War begins. This sense of isolation adds a layer of depth to the narrative, making the characters more relatable and the story more engaging. The reviewer appreciates how this theme is woven into the historical context, enhancing the overall reading experience.

Quick quotes

    many of her characters have some sort of 'otherness'

    Simon feels pretty cut off once he goes to war

    This adds a layer of depth to the narrative

Rosemary Sutcliff Official Website · 2022-05-21
compelling 4.50

The story is compelling and unbiased, vividly describing the troubled times of the Civil War. The historical accuracy and depth make it a standout.

This review highlights the book's ability to immerse readers in the English Civil War with a compelling and unbiased narrative. The vivid and accurate descriptions of the historical context are particularly praised, making it a standout piece of historical fiction. The reviewer appreciates the depth and authenticity, which bring the period to life. They also note that the story's unbiased perspective adds to its credibility and engagement.

Quick quotes

    Rosemary Sutcliff has written a compelling and unbiased story of the troubled times of the civil war

    describing vividly and accurately the historical context

    The depth and authenticity bring the period to life

Perfect Retort Blog · 2021-01-09
absorbing 4.00

The book is absorbing and realistic, with some violence and gruesome deaths that are likely glossed over in juvenile historical fiction. It is recommended for older children and adults.

The reviewer finds 'Simon' to be an absorbing and realistic portrayal of the English Civil War. They appreciate the book's willingness to include violence and gruesome deaths, which adds a layer of realism often glossed over in juvenile historical fiction. The reviewer recommends it for older children and adults, highlighting its ability to engage and educate readers about the period. They also note that the book's realistic approach makes it a valuable addition to historical fiction.

Quick quotes

    This book definitely had some violence and gruesome deaths, as is realistic

    likely glossed over in some juvenile historical fiction

    This is a fine story, beautifully written

Appears in Lists