The reviewer finds the book clumsy and annoying, criticizing it as a pastiche of a crime novel. They believe Val McDermid is capable of better writing.
The reviewer expresses disappointment with The Torment of Others, finding it clumsy and unnecessary. They feel that Val McDermid, who is known for her excellent writing, has not lived up to her usual standards in this book. The reviewer criticizes the plot as a pastiche of a crime novel, lacking the depth and originality that one would expect from McDermid. They suggest that the book is unworthy of her usual caliber of work.
Quick quotes
But it's clumsy, annoying, and unnecessary.
Val McDermid can write well, I've no doubt about that.
But this is a pastiche of a crime novel, and unworthy of her usual standards.