The book is praised for its detailed and well-researched narrative on the fall of the Ottoman Empire and the creation of the modern Middle East. However, some critics note its focus on British perspectives and lack of deeper analysis on Middle Eastern cultures.
A Peace to End All Peace is widely recognized for its comprehensive exploration of the historical events surrounding World War I and the subsequent shaping of the Middle East. Readers appreciate the book's thorough research and engaging narrative style, which provides essential context for understanding current geopolitical dynamics. The detailed accounts of British and allied actions are particularly highlighted, offering valuable insights into the region's history. However, some reviewers point out that the book primarily presents a victor's history, with a strong emphasis on British perspectives at the expense of Middle Eastern viewpoints. While the personalities and events are well-documented, the analysis and connections to post-WWI events are concentrated in the later chapters, which some find to be the most compelling parts of the book. Overall, the book is seen as a crucial resource for understanding the complexities of the Middle East's modern history, though it could benefit from a more balanced approach.
Quick quotes
Remarkably interesting, well researched, narrative approach to a WWI history focused on the actions of Britain and allies towards what became the Middle East. Essential foundation for understanding that region, and America’s and Britain’s policies towards it, today.
This is a victor’s history, a British one primarily, at the expense of perspectives from the Middle Eastern cultures affected.
This book instead focuses on the European involvement over the decade or so surrounding World War I. It illustrates the naïveté, the hubris, the complexity, the confusion of those who would try to control forces formed over centuries.