The book is a lightweight but readable account of the Roosevelts during World War II, ideal for those seeking a glossy portrait without challenging preconceptions. The reviewer criticizes the book for being a hagiography that avoids examining FDR's flaws and questionable decisions.
Doris Kearns Goodwin's 'No Ordinary Time' is an earnest but lightweight account of Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt during the World War II years. The book is very readable and presents a glossy portrait of the Roosevelts, making it ideal for readers who want a straightforward, uncritical look at the couple. However, the reviewer criticizes the book for being a hagiography that avoids examining FDR's flaws and questionable decisions. The reviewer points out that Goodwin presents the Roosevelts as demi-gods, avoiding critical questions about FDR's actions and decisions. For example, the book does not adequately address FDR's decision to run for a third term, his handling of the internment of Japanese-Americans, or the significant debt accumulated during his presidency. The reviewer also criticizes Goodwin for not exploring the impact of FDR's polio on his governance and personal relationships. Overall, the book is recommended for those with limited intellectual curiosity, as it does not delve deeply into the complexities and controversies of the Roosevelts' lives and actions.
Quick quotes
The book is an extremely lightweight, but very readable account of the Roosevelts during the War years.
It is an act of extraordinary irresponsibility to put the country in a position where it would be governed by a virtual unknown in time of war.
Goodwin answers none of these questions, & for the most part doesn't raise them, because it's probably never occurred to her to ask them.