The book is a fascinating exploration into the wonder of consciousness, but it is marred by human hubris and a lack of scientific rigor. The emotional and personal aspects are well-documented, but the book's claims about octopus consciousness are not sufficiently supported by scientific evidence.
Notes of Oak's review of The Soul of an Octopus praises the book for its fascinating exploration into the wonder of consciousness. However, the reviewer notes that the book is marred by human hubris and a lack of scientific rigor. The emotional and personal aspects of the author's experiences with octopuses are well-documented, but the reviewer feels that the book's claims about octopus consciousness are not sufficiently supported by scientific evidence. Despite these criticisms, the book is still seen as a valuable read for those interested in the emotional and personal aspects of human-animal relationships.
Quick quotes
A book review of Sy Montgomery's nonfiction text – The Soul of an Octopus: A Surprising Exploration into the Wonder of Consciousness.
The book is marred by human hubris and a lack of scientific rigor.
The emotional and personal aspects of the author's experiences with octopuses are well-documented, but the book's claims about octopus consciousness are not sufficiently supported by scientific evidence.