The book is packed with ideas and characters, which is both its strength and weakness. The setting is atmospheric and the protagonist's unique situation is compelling.
This reviewer found The Alchemy of Stone to be a rich tapestry of ideas and characters, which makes it a compelling read. However, the sheer density of these elements can sometimes feel overwhelming, as if the book is trying to do too much in too short a space. The setting is particularly noteworthy, creating an atmosphere that is both haunting and immersive. The protagonist, an automaton named Mattie, is a standout feature, offering a fresh perspective that is both intriguing and poignant. The reviewer appreciates the originality and depth of the world-building, even if it occasionally feels like the plot could benefit from more breathing room.
Quick quotes
For a relatively short book, The Alchemy of Stone is crammed full of amazing ideas and characters.
This is both a strength and a weakness.
Mattie's situation, neither human nor mindless, is compelling.