Enemy At The Gates: The Battle For Stalingrad

by William Craig
Enemy At The Gates: The Battle For Stalingrad cover
Good Books rating 4.08
Buy online
Amazon
Format/Price Check
Technical
  • ID: 6572
  • Added: 2025-11-23
  • Updated: 2025-11-23
  • Reviews: 3
Reviews
The Storygraph · 2025-11-23
astounding 4.75

The book is described as astounding and cinematic, with a narrative that feels like watching a movie. It is noted for its detailed account of the Battle of Stalingrad.

This review compares the book to a movie, highlighting its ability to draw the reader in with a vivid and engaging narrative. The reviewer was inspired to read the book after watching the film 'Enemy at the Gates' and found the book to be even more compelling. They appreciate the detailed account of the battle and the way the author brings the events to life. The reviewer also notes that the book provides a comprehensive understanding of the Battle of Stalingrad, making it a must-read for history enthusiasts.

Quick quotes

    Astounding! Reading this book felt like watching a movie.

    I was originally inspired to read this book because of the movie Enemy at the Gates (2001).

    The book provides a comprehensive understanding of the Battle of Stalingrad.

Bill Manzi · 2018-03-17
harrowing 4.50

The book provides a detailed and harrowing account of the Battle of Stalingrad, focusing on the human cost and the brutal conditions faced by soldiers. It is praised for its vivid and gripping narrative.

This review highlights the book's ability to convey the horrors of war through personal stories and eyewitness accounts. The author does an excellent job of showing how the battle affected both the German and Russian soldiers, making the reader feel the weight of each decision and action. The reviewer appreciates the depth of research and the emotional impact of the narrative, which makes the book a compelling read. They also note that the book's detailed descriptions of the battlefield and the soldiers' experiences create a vivid and immersive experience for the reader.

Quick quotes

    Craig shows us how an army begins to wither and die in excruciating detail, with eyewitness accounts of the horrors involved in this battle.

    The book provides a detailed and harrowing account of the Battle of Stalingrad, focusing on the human cost and the brutal conditions faced by soldiers.

    It is praised for its vivid and gripping narrative.

The New York Times · 1973-08-19
critical 3.00

The book is criticized for its lack of clarity on how the author arrived at certain conclusions. It is described as an inhuman battle that is well-documented but lacks depth in some areas.

This review from The New York Times points out that while the book is well-researched and provides a detailed account of the Battle of Stalingrad, it lacks clarity in some areas. The reviewer notes that the author's conclusions are not always well-supported, which can be frustrating for readers looking for a deeper understanding of the events. Despite this, the book is praised for its thorough documentation of the battle and its impact on the soldiers involved. The reviewer suggests that the book could benefit from more analysis and interpretation of the events.

Quick quotes

    To go a little deeper, though this book is expressively titled 'Enemy at the Gates,' it is by no means clear how he arrived there.

    This is no doubt an inhuman battle that is well-documented but lacks depth in some areas.

    The book could benefit from more analysis and interpretation of the events.

Appears in Lists