Nobody’s Baby But Mine

Nobody’s Baby But Mine cover
Good Books rating 2.83
Buy online
Technical
  • ID: 6465
  • Added: 2025-11-18
  • Updated: 2025-11-18
  • Reviews: 3
Reviews
goodreads.com · Unknown · 2025-11-20
brilliant 5.00

The book is a heartwarming tale of two seemingly incompatible people learning to love and accept each other despite their differences. It explores themes of intelligence, societal norms, and the power of love to transcend barriers, all wrapped in a delightful romantic comedy.

Nobody’s Baby But Mine by Susan Elizabeth Phillips is a romantic comedy that defies its quirky premise to deliver a heartwarming tale of love and self-acceptance. The story revolves around Jane Darlington, a brilliant but insecure physics professor, and Cal Bonner, a not-so-bright former football star. Jane's misguided attempt to 'dilute' her genes by having a child with Cal leads to a series of hilarious and outrageous events, ultimately resulting in a deeply satisfying romance. The book's strength lies in its masterful storytelling and character development, with Phillips creating multi-dimensional characters that feel real and relatable. Beneath the humor and romance, the novel explores poignant themes of societal attitudes towards intelligence and the stigma faced by those deemed 'too smart'. The reviewer found the book to be a delightful and thought-provoking read that will stay with them long after the final page. They highly recommend it to fans of romantic comedies and character-driven stories.


Quick quotes

    She’d been a lonely little girl, too smart for her own good, too different to fit in. She’d learned early on that being brilliant wasn’t an asset, but a liability, something that set her apart from the other kids and made her a target for their cruelty.

    What began as a seemingly outrageous premise had blossomed into a heartwarming tale of love, self-acceptance, and the beauty of embracing our differences.

    It’s a book that will surprise you, make you laugh, and ultimately leave you with a warm, fuzzy feeling in your heart — a reminder that love can blossom in the most unexpected places, if we’re willing to open our hearts and minds.

app.thestorygraph.com · Unknown · 2025-11-20
entertaining 3.50

The book is a hilarious and entertaining rom-com with strong female characters and a unique plot. However, some readers found the male protagonist's machismo and the sudden shift from hatred to love to be problematic. The book is enjoyable but has some flaws that prevent it from being a perfect read.

Nobody's Baby But Mine is a rom-com that has been praised for its humor and strong female characters. The story is set in a different time and features a unique plot that keeps readers engaged. The female characters are particularly well-developed and enjoyable to read about. However, some readers have criticized the male protagonist for his machismo and the sudden shift from hatred to love between the main characters. The book is also criticized for not giving enough importance to the pregnancy subplot, which was a key factor for some readers. Despite these flaws, the book is generally enjoyable and has been praised for its addictive writing style and well-developed secondary characters. The relationship between the parents of the main character is also a highlight of the book.


Quick quotes

    The female characters were amazing and so much fun, I love me some strongminded women.

    Empezando con el machismo de Cal, ya que algunos de sus comentarios y actitudes simplemente se me atragantaron mientras leía.

    Absolutely bonkers plot, questionable likability of characters, but somehow also compulsively readable.

kayedacus.com · Unknown · 2016-02-13
disappointing 0.00

The reviewer found the main characters unlikable and the plot problematic, particularly the nonconsensual procreation aspect. They disliked the heroine's ignorant approach to genetics and the hero's alpha-hole behavior, leading them to abandon the book at 25%.

The reviewer struggled with 'Nobody’s Baby But Mine' by Susan Elizabeth Phillips, finding both main characters deeply flawed. The heroine, a supposed genius, displays ignorance about genetics and makes illogical decisions, while the hero is portrayed as sexist and narcissistic. The reviewer was particularly bothered by the nonconsensual procreation plotline and the hero's forced marriage proposal. They also found the trope of a desperate woman wanting a baby unappealing. The reviewer's background in a family of scientists made the portrayal of intelligent characters even more frustrating. Ultimately, they found the book so unpleasant that they abandoned it at the 25% mark.


Quick quotes

    I made it to the 25% mark in the book — when she forces him to have sex for nonconsensual procreation the second time. And at that point, I put the book down, because I just couldn’t stand to read any further.

    The heroine: She’s supposed to be some kind of child-prodigy science genius, but she is a COMPLETE IDIOT about genetics, biology, and nature-vs-nurture.

    And the “hero” — what an Alpha-Hole! Sexist. Ageist. Narcissistic. Demeaning to those around him. Only out for himself.