As a standalone novel, Earthborn is decent, but as a conclusion to the Homecoming series, it is considered disappointing. The reviewer expresses a sense of wishing for a better ending.
The reviewer has mixed feelings about Earthborn. They find it to be a decent novel on its own, but they are critical of it as a conclusion to the Homecoming series. The sense of disappointment is palpable, as they express a wish for a more satisfying ending. This suggests that while the book has its merits, it falls short of meeting the expectations set by the previous installments in the series. The reviewer's disappointment indicates that the ending might feel rushed or unsatisfying, leaving them wanting more from the conclusion of the saga.
Quick quotes
On its own, Earthborn is a decent novel.
As a conclusion to the Homecoming series, I think it's disgraceful.
After reading this, I found myself wishing that the ...