From Potter’s Field

From Potter’s Field cover
Good Books rating 2.75
Buy online
Technical
  • ID: 6331
  • Added: 2025-11-12
  • Updated: 2025-11-12
  • Reviews: 3
Reviews
thtswhatsheread.wordpress.com · Unknown · 2025-11-15
disappointing 1.00

The reviewer found the main character, Kay Scarpetta, arrogant and unlikable, with a tendency to over-emotionalize her cases. The writing style was criticized for being overly dramatic and filled with run-on sentences. The reviewer also disliked the recurring theme of criminals targeting Scarpetta personally, which they found unrealistic and self-indulgent. Despite some humorous moments, the overall experience was negative, leading to a low rating.

The reviewer had a mixed experience with 'From Potter’s Field' by Patricia Cornwell. They found the main character, Kay Scarpetta, to be arrogant and unlikable, with a severe superiority complex that made her difficult to connect with. The writing style was criticized for being overly dramatic and filled with run-on sentences that needed editing. The reviewer also disliked the recurring theme of criminals targeting Scarpetta personally, which they found unrealistic and self-indulgent. However, there were some humorous moments, such as Scarpetta's snobbish attitude towards beer and her judgy comments about others' drinking habits. Despite these moments, the overall experience was negative, and the reviewer could only read one of her books a year to avoid frustration. They predicted that the series would continue to decline in quality, with Scarpetta becoming increasingly annoying and the plots becoming more ludicrous. The reviewer gave the book a low rating of 2 stars.


Quick quotes

    God,” I said with a loud sigh. “You were lured right into it.” I stared off, almost sick. “It’s not just because of how good you are at what you do. It’s also because of me.

    You have to leave it outside the door like stinking crime scene clothes.

    The blood of this woman whose name we did not know brightly stained snow, and beyond the arena of her hideous death Central Park dissolved into thick, foreboding shadows.

kirkusreviews.com · Unknown · 2025-11-15
excellent 4.00

From Potter's Field is a gripping and well-crafted mystery that showcases Cornwell's signature attention to detail and forensic expertise. The story is engaging, with a complex plot and well-developed characters, though some may find the pacing slow in parts.

From Potter's Field is a standout entry in the Kay Scarpetta series, offering a compelling blend of forensic science and suspense. The novel's intricate plot and vivid descriptions of autopsy procedures are hallmarks of Cornwell's writing, making it a must-read for fans of the genre. The pacing, however, may not be as brisk as some readers might prefer, but the depth of character development and the meticulous attention to detail more than compensate for this. The story's exploration of themes like justice and the human condition adds layers of complexity, making it a thought-provoking read. Overall, it's a book that will keep readers on the edge of their seats, eager to unravel the mysteries alongside Scarpetta.


Quick quotes

    The narrative is as meticulous as an autopsy report, with every detail contributing to the overall suspense.

    Cornwell's ability to weave forensic science into a gripping story is unparalleled.

    The pacing is deliberate, allowing the reader to savor the intricacies of the investigation.

app.thestorygraph.com · Unknown · 2025-11-15
mixed 3.25

The book is praised for its action and excitement, but some readers found the ending anticlimactic and the character development uneven. The story is engaging, but the resolution of the main conflict is disappointing.

From Potter's Field is a thrilling addition to the series, with a fast-paced plot and intense action sequences. The characters are well-developed, though some readers found the resolution of the main antagonist's arc unsatisfying. The book's setting in New York City adds to its atmosphere, and the interactions between characters are a highlight. However, the ending feels rushed and anticlimactic, leaving some readers disappointed. Despite this, the book is enjoyable for fans of the series and those looking for a gripping mystery.


Quick quotes

    She spent three books building up to catching this guy, and then it was over in two anti-climatic paragraphs, it was really quite a let down. The rest of the book was very good and exciting though.

    Right now frankly I need the escapism.

    Although I started this book several months ago, I only finished it 2-3 days ago. I am concurrently reading the Scarpetta Series by Patricia Cornwell and the Temperance Brennan Series by Kathy Reichs and found myself overwhelmed with medical terminology.