Iris Chang's book provides a vivid and powerful account of the Nanking Massacre, drawing from extensive research and personal narratives. However, the book is criticized for blending facts with nationalistic assumptions and lacking a bibliography.
Iris Chang's 'The Rape of Nanking: The Forgotten Holocaust of World War II' offers a compelling and emotionally charged narrative of one of the most horrific events during the Pacific War. Chang's writing is praised for its ability to convey the brutality and human impact of the massacre, making it a shocking and unforgettable read. The book's extensive use of sources, including diaries and trial records, adds legitimacy to the narrative. However, the reviewer notes that Chang's work is not without flaws. The blending of facts with nationalistic assumptions and the absence of a bibliography are significant drawbacks. Despite these issues, the book provides a comprehensive view of the massacre, addressing the events leading up to it and the ongoing repercussions. Chang's analysis of the reasons behind the Japanese troops' actions and the attempts to erase knowledge of the massacre are particularly informative. Overall, while the book is highly readable and impactful, it is important to approach it with a critical eye.
Quick quotes
Chang has written a vivid and highly readable account of the Nanking Massacre, one of the great atrocities inflicted on China by Japanese troops during the Pacific War.
The writing is Chang's strong point. She describes in succinct and powerful language the battles leading up to the Nanking Massacre and the Massacre itself.
The most interesting aspect of Chang's work is her blending of rumor and fact to flesh out a very interesting narrative.