The reviewer finds significant issues with the setting, plot, and characters in the first section. The middle section is seen as a standout, but the overall structure is criticized for being strange and disjointed.
Nicholas Whyte expresses disappointment with the first section of the novel, citing problems with the setting, plot, and characters. They find the middle section to be a standout, particularly for its unique portrayal of an alien romance. However, they criticize the overall structure of the novel, describing it as strange and disjointed. Despite these issues, they acknowledge the novel's ambitious scope and scientific depth, which they find thought-provoking and engaging.
Quick quotes
So, basically, I found huge problems with the setting, plot and characters of the first section.
The second bit, 'The Gods Themselves', supposedly represents...
It's clever, unsettling, and oddly beautiful.