Republic

by Plato
Republic cover
Good Books rating 3.88
Buy online
Waterstones
Paperback • £3.99–£19.99 Hardback • £44.99
Bookshop
Format • £7.59–£10.44
Amazon
Format/Price Check
Technical
  • ID: 5989
  • Added: 2025-10-29
  • Updated: 2025-12-30
  • Formats: 22
  • Reviews: 4
Reviews
goodreads.com · Unknown · 2025-12-11
profound 4.00

The reviewer finds Plato's Republic a profound exploration of justice and governance, though some arguments may seem outdated. The dialogue format is engaging, but the idealistic vision of society is critiqued for its impracticality.

Plato's Republic is a cornerstone of political philosophy, delving deeply into the nature of justice and the ideal state. The reviewer appreciates the Socratic method and the rich discussions on morality, education, and the role of philosophers in governance. However, they note that some of Plato's ideas, such as the rigid class structure and the exclusion of poets, may not resonate with modern readers. The vision of an ideal society, while inspiring, is seen as overly idealistic and detached from practical realities. The dialogue format keeps the text engaging, but the reviewer questions the feasibility of implementing such a utopian vision in the real world.

Quick quotes

    The Republic is a profound exploration of justice and governance.

    The dialogue format is engaging, but the idealistic vision of society is critiqued for its impracticality.

    The vision of an ideal society, while inspiring, is seen as overly idealistic and detached from practical realities.

marxandphilosophy.org.uk · Unknown · 2025-12-11
profound 4.50

The reviewer finds Plato's Republic a profound and influential work, though they note its complexity and the challenges it presents to modern readers. They appreciate its exploration of justice and the ideal state, but also acknowledge its flaws and the need for critical engagement.

Plato's Republic is a monumental work that has shaped Western philosophy for centuries. They admire its depth and the way it grapples with fundamental questions about justice, the ideal state, and the nature of the good life. However, they also recognize that its arguments can be dense and sometimes convoluted, making it a challenging read. They appreciate the dialogue format, which brings the ideas to life through the interactions of Socrates and his interlocutors. They also note that some of the conclusions drawn, such as the role of philosopher-kings, may not align with contemporary political thought. Overall, they find the Republic to be a rich and rewarding text, but one that requires patience and careful consideration. They believe it offers valuable insights into the human condition and the pursuit of justice, even if some of its specific proposals may be controversial or outdated.

Quick quotes

    Plato's Republic is a profound and influential work that has shaped Western philosophy for centuries.

    They admire its depth and the way it grapples with fundamental questions about justice, the ideal state, and the nature of the good life.

    However, they also recognize that its arguments can be dense and sometimes convoluted, making it a challenging read.

app.thestorygraph.com · Unknown · 2025-12-11
profound 4.50

The Republic by Plato is a profound exploration of justice, society, and governance through dialogues between Socrates and other philosophers. The book presents innovative ideas about societal structure, education, and the role of women, though some concepts may seem controversial or impractical today.

The Republic by Plato is a must-read for anyone interested in philosophy and political science. The book centers around dialogues between Socrates and other philosophers, debating the definition of justice and how to create a just society. The discussions cover a wide range of topics, including the structure of society, education, family dynamics, and the role of women. While some ideas may seem progressive for their time, others may appear flawed or impractical. The book also delves into the life cycle of a republic, from timocracy to tyranny, and the importance of merit-based social ranking. Despite some dense and methodical passages, the book offers profound insights that have stayed with the reviewer long after reading. It is recommended for those who can handle its complexity and are willing to engage with its challenging ideas.

Quick quotes

    I found this a truly worthwhile experience and months later the concepts and ideas have stuck with me and I find it stimulates further ideas on societal and government matters.

    There is no question in my mind that this should be a must read for everyone who can handle it.

    The entire book is based on the dialogue between philosophers and at times it can be methodical and at times feeling inconsequential.

eclectic-indulgence.blogspot.com · Unknown · 2012-04-14
critical 2.50

The reviewer finds Plato's arguments in 'Republic' to be flawed and based on presumptive statements, but acknowledges the book's influence on Western civilization and its ability to provoke deep thought.

The reviewer criticizes Plato's use of straw arguments and manipulative discussions in 'Republic', pointing out that the book lacks realistic solutions. However, they recognize Plato's significant influence on Western philosophy and his skill in crafting dialogues that challenge readers to think deeply. The reviewer appreciates Plato's ability to provoke thought and engage readers in intellectual exercises, despite the flaws in his arguments. The book is seen as a foundational text that encourages critical thinking and debate.

Quick quotes

    Plato is stupid.

    Every single one of his works goes like this:

    The moral of the story is: Plato is stupid.

    All the criticisms of Plato are valid.

    He wants you to think, and to think deeply.

Appears in Lists