The book is critiqued for feeling like a loose collection of short stories rather than a cohesive novel. The constant stream of new characters is noted as a drawback.
In this Reddit discussion, several readers felt that Everfair lacked the cohesion of a traditional novel. They described it as feeling more like a collection of short stories, with a constant stream of new characters that made it difficult to connect with the narrative. While they appreciated the ambition and creativity of the book, they found the execution lacking in terms of plot and character development. The reviewers suggest that the book could have benefited from a more focused narrative to make it more engaging and cohesive.
Quick quotes
This book really feels like a loose collection of short stories rather than a novel.
The constant stream of new characters makes it hard to connect with the story.
The worldbuilding is impressive, but the plot feels disjointed and unfocused.