The reviewer found the book to be a mix of boring and fascinating, with some stories being iconic and others dated. They appreciated the outpour of love for stars and technology but noted that it was from an old perspective. The reviewer also highlighted the emotional impact of 'Flowers for Algernon' and the intriguing ideas in the 1940s and 50s stories.
The reviewer started by mentioning that some of the stories were difficult to read due to their old-fashioned writing and male gaze. However, they found the stories from the 1930s onwards to be much better, with fascinating and creative ideas. The reviewer particularly enjoyed 'Flowers for Algernon', which still makes them weep despite multiple readings. They also appreciated the variety of authors and the rich discussion it could spark among sci-fi nerds. Overall, they found it to be a good read and a great beginning for discussions.
Quick quotes
The stories got better in the 1930s, though. The 1940s and 50s brought us fascinating, creative ideas in sci-fi, and I found myself devouring this volume.
A small note and warning for those who have not yet read Flowers for Algernon: get ready with a tissue or two.
Overall, a good read, a nice sampling, and a great beginning for rich discussion amongst fellow sci-fi nerds.