Short and Tall

by Ellie B. Morris
Short and Tall cover
Good Books rating 4.75
Technical
  • ID: 5707
  • Added: 2025-10-24
  • Updated: 2025-10-24
  • Reviews: 4
Reviews
goodreads.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
brilliant 5.00

The reviewer has a strong affection for this book, not just for its story but also for the personal memories it evokes. They appreciate the character development, especially of Dumbledore and Lupin, and the philosophical depth the series brings, such as the impact of life's challenges and the power of happy memories.

The reviewer has a deep connection to this book, as it was their introduction to the Harry Potter series. They highlight the rich character development, particularly of Dumbledore and Lupin, and the unexpected twists in the plot. The philosophical themes, such as the impact of life's challenges and the comfort found in happy memories, are particularly appreciated. The reviewer also expresses disappointment in the movie adaptation, noting the omission of key elements like the Quidditch Final. Overall, they find the book magical and deeply meaningful.

Quick quotes

    I love this book a lot not just because of the story but because of the memory as well.

    The series brings a lot of philosophical depth, I think.

    I cannot, and perhaps do not want to, delve into a lot of details. It goes without saying, I hope you find the magic like I did.

rwszupzmsadbjqghhiwjxwntmpecjm.thestorygraph.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
enjoyable 4.50

The reviewer enjoyed this book, finding it to be a well-balanced standalone in the series. They appreciated the mix of humor, character development, and intriguing plot points, though they noted some moments of casual acceptance of questionable behaviors.

The reviewer found this book to be a standout in the series, striking a balance between the lighter tone of earlier books and the darker themes of later installments. They particularly enjoyed the character interactions and the way the story explored relationships and personal growth. The reviewer also noted some interesting observations about the world-building and the characters' behaviors, though they found certain aspects, like the casual acceptance of corporal punishment, to be a product of the time. Overall, they appreciated the book's ability to blend humor and seriousness, making it a favorite among the standalone books in the series.

Quick quotes

    A flavorful foreboding, it plies expanded bandwidth, like ripened fruit, and more acute: a sweet and spicy sandwich.

    Of all the books, most people say this one's their favorite. I believe a big reason why is it hits the sweet-spot between the middle-grade fare of the first two and the dark seriousness of the last four.

    On the whole, I enjoyed the last four more, as serial installments of the 'Voldemort is back' storyline. But of the standalone books, I like this best.

archive.bookfrom.net · Unknown · 2025-10-24
enjoyable 4.50

The reviewer enjoyed rereading Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, appreciating the detailed world-building and humorous references. They found the special editions with house-specific content particularly engaging and recommended the book for both new and returning readers.

The reviewer found Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban to be a delightful reread, especially with the added house-specific content in the special editions. They appreciated the detailed world-building, including the introduction of new magical artifacts like the Marauders Map and the village of Hogsmeade. The reviewer also enjoyed the humorous references and the way the story balances adventure with the everyday life of school friends. The special editions, with their house-specific discussions and illustrations, added an extra layer of enjoyment. Overall, they found the book enjoyable and recommended it for both new readers and those revisiting the series.

Quick quotes

    The imaginative world invented so entertaining.

    Aimed at children, the circumvention the protagonists attain from pesky adult interference will no doubt be a delight to younger readers.

    The book easily stood up to rereading. Enjoyable and recommended.

oceanofpdf.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
excellent 5.00

The reviewer enjoyed the darker tone and sinister elements of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, finding it a pivotal book in the series. They appreciated the introduction of new characters and the fresh narrative, making it an engaging read.

The reviewer found Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban to be a standout book in the series, appreciating its darker tone and the introduction of more sinister elements. They enjoyed the fresh narrative and the introduction of new characters, which added depth to the story. The book's shorter length made it an approachable and quick read, and the reviewer managed to re-read it in just over a week. The mix of familiarity and new elements made the pace and character introductions easy to follow, and the reviewer enjoyed the overall experience of re-reading the book and the series.

Quick quotes

    The more sinister aspects of the narrative really worked for me.

    Whilst short and sweet, it introduces characters such as the dementors, who go on to have a more significant role later on in the series.

    I really enjoyed my re-read of this book and the whole series!

Appears in Lists