A Good Day to Die

A Good Day to Die cover
Good Books rating 3.25
Technical
  • ID: 5607
  • Added: 2025-10-24
  • Updated: 2025-10-24
  • Formats: 2
  • Reviews: 2
Reviews
goodmenproject.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
excellent 4.50

A Good Day to Die is a novel that captures the existentialism brought about by drugs and war, told through the journey of a Vietnam vet and his girlfriend. The book is praised for its fine rendering of the love affair between rednecks and the rest of us, and its deceptively off-handed style.

A Good Day to Die is a novel that delves into the casual but pervasive existentialism brought about by drugs and war. The story follows a Georgia cracker Vietnam vet with a battle-scarred face and his beautiful girlfriend as they embark on a journey across small US towns. The book is filled with booze, sex, dope, and country music, offering a mindless, inconsequentially cheerful ride that ultimately leads to an inconsequential accident. The deceptively off-handed style of the novel may blind readers to its depth, but it is considered one of the best books written in America on this subject. It also presents a fine rendering of the love affair between rednecks and the rest of us, a combination of nostalgia and escapism that induces Ivy Leaguers to trade the respectable life for the wildness they usually come into contact with only at the movies.


Quick quotes

    If you've got to go, you might as well do it by blowing up a small unecologically-minded dam on the Clearwater in Idaho, especially if you're a Georgia cracker Vietnam vet with a battle-scarred face, a beautiful chick who excites you about as much as a couple of reds, and enough pills to simulate every mood in the world, plus some.

    The deceptively off-handed style may unfortunately blind readers to the fact that this may be the best book written in America about the casual but pervasive existentialism brought about by drugs and war.

    It also presents as fine a rendering as we're likely to see in a long time about the little-heralded love affair between the rednecks and the rest of us, a combination of nostalgia and escapism that induces Ivy Leaguers to trade the respectable life for the wildness they usually come into contact with only at the movies.

rogueliterarysociety.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
disappointing 2.00

The reviewer criticizes the novel for its machismo and self-pity, finding the protagonist's self-loathing and passive despair tedious rather than tragic. They question why a talented writer would waste his abilities on such an adolescent and outdated narrative.

The reviewer takes issue with the novel's portrayal of machismo and self-pity, arguing that the protagonist's constant self-loathing and passive despair do not make him tragic or heroic, but rather tedious. They find the narrative outdated and question why a talented writer would choose to explore such themes. The reviewer also criticizes the protagonist's idealized love for Sylvia and his voyeuristic participation in her relationship with Tim, finding it unconvincing and uninteresting. Overall, they see the novel as an adolescent work that fails to live up to the writer's potential.


Quick quotes

    Why Harrison is content to waste an excellent narrative talent on this kind of super-machismo a-man's-a-man stuff is certainly puzzling.

    But people who aren't in struggle just aren't grandly tragic or heroic; no matter how aggressively self-critical, and those who mistake passivity and despair for struggle, or some kind of admirable rebellion, are in special trouble.

    In fiction, they become tedious. "A Good Day to Die" is an adolescent book by a talented writer who, on the basis of it, is experienced enough to know better than to preach its me-burned-out-Tarzan dogma.