Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption

Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption cover
Good Books rating 4.0
Technical
  • ID: 5550
  • Added: 2025-10-24
  • Updated: 2025-10-24
  • Reviews: 2
Reviews
bookbrowse.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
excellent 5.00

The collection of Guy de Maupassant's short fiction is highly praised for its masterful storytelling and beautiful translations. The stories are rooted in 19th-century France and are described as achingly gorgeous, with a mix of masterpieces and comic tales.

This collection of Guy de Maupassant's short fiction is composed of thirty tales translated from the French by Roger Colet. Several of the tales, particularly _Boule de Suif_, _Two Friends_, _In the Spring_, _A Duel_, _The Devil_, and _The Horla_, are counted as masterpieces of the form. Others play for the comic, including _In the Woods_, _The Signal_, _Guillemot Rock_, _The Conservatory_, and _The Decoration_. The stories convey a time and a place, most of them being firmly rooted in France of the 1870s and 1880s. There is a beauty and a languor in Guy de Maupassant's descriptions which makes these some of the most achingly gorgeous short tales ever read, beautifully translated by Colet. The closest comparison is to some of the short stories of Émile Zola, although Zola and Maupassant were very different writers. If this sounds intriguing, finding a copy of this edition is highly recommended.


Quick quotes

    Several of the tales, particularly _Boule de Suif_, _Two Friends_, _In the Spring_, _A Duel_, _The Devil_, and _The Horla_ (this last story often anthologized, and rightly so, as it happens), must, I think, be counted as little short of masterpieces of the form.

    There is a beauty and a languor in Guy de Maupassant’s descriptions which makes these some of the most achingly gorgeous short tales I have ever read, beautifully translated by Colet.

    Highly recommended. Five stars.

earnestlyeccentric.wordpress.com · Unknown · 2024-12-15
confused 3.00

The reviewer is confused by the lack of consensus on Guy de Maupassant's best stories, finding a mix of brilliant writing and glib nonsense in various collections. They question the exclusion of famous stories like 'The Diamond Necklace' and the varying opinions on Maupassant's work.

The reviewer has recently delved into Guy de Maupassant's stories, expecting to find a consensus on his best works. However, they were surprised to find that different collections of his stories vary greatly, with little overlap. Some collections exclude famous stories like 'The Diamond Necklace,' which the reviewer finds puzzling. The reviewer also notes that opinions on Maupassant's work are divided, with some critics praising his writing while others dismiss it as trivial. They are left confused by the lack of agreement on Maupassant's best stories and plan to continue exploring his work.


Quick quotes

    I have read, or am reading: Selected Short Stories, Penguin Classics, 1971, tr. Roger Colet, 30 stories

    In all three books brilliantly written stories alternate with glib nonsense.

    The two translations from the 1970s not only omit 'The Diamond Necklace,' but do so almost angrily, as a matter of principle, avoiding the distortion of that horrible trick story.