The Man Without Qualities

The Man Without Qualities cover
Good Books rating 4.31
Buy online
Technical
  • ID: 5517
  • Added: 2025-10-24
  • Updated: 2025-10-24
  • Formats: 1
  • Reviews: 4
Reviews
streetsense.substack.com · Unknown · 2025-10-24
brilliant 4.50

Jane Smiley reviews TH White's The Once and Future King, a serious and delightful work that explores the complexities of human nature and governance. The novel is full of insights and comic scenes, and White's portrayal of characters like Guenever is sympathetic and rich.

Jane Smiley's review of TH White's The Once and Future King highlights the novel's depth and richness. The work, composed over 20 years, is a serious and delightful exploration of Arthurian legend, filled with insights into human nature and governance. White's portrayal of characters like Guenever is particularly sympathetic and rich, and the novel is full of comic scenes that deal with some of Malory's absurdities. The underlying premise of the novel is that the proper arrangement and resolution of personal relationships can result in social peace, and the novel ends with the implication that Arthur will try again to create the kingdom he hoped for.


Quick quotes

    The Once and Future King is full of insights, scenes, and flourishes that are really quite astonishing.

    White's novel is intense and rich.

    The underlying premise of the novel as a form is that such rationalisation and reconciliation is possible, because the novel always tries to set the individual into the social context.

The New York Review of Books · Michael Hofmann · 2020-03-26
great 4.25

The novel is described as unfinished but inherently endless, with Musil's exploration of infinities. The reviewer appreciates the novel's depth and complexity.

Michael Hofmann discusses the novel's unfinished nature, describing it as inherently endless due to Musil's exploration of infinities. He appreciates the depth and complexity of the novel, noting its unique approach to storytelling. Hofmann highlights Musil's ability to delve into profound themes, making the novel a rich and thought-provoking read. He also mentions the novel's enduring relevance and its ability to captivate readers despite its unfinished state.


Quick quotes

    Yes, it's unfinished (“inherently endless,” as Max Brod said of ...

    Musil's exploration of infinities is both profound and captivating.

    The novel's depth and complexity make it a rewarding read.

nytimes.com · Unknown · 2019-12-05
profound 4.00

The book is a profound exploration of Arthurian legend, blending historical context, character studies, and philosophical questions. It's praised for its depth and complexity, though some find it slow and disjointed.

The Once and Future King is a monumental work that reimagines the Arthurian legend with a focus on human emotions and actions. The narrative is divided into four books, each offering a unique perspective on the characters and their struggles. The first section is engaging and reminiscent of the Disney movie, but the story takes a darker turn, exploring themes of deception, unhappiness, and the consequences of actions. The book is both depressing and fascinating, with moments of humor and deep philosophical questions. Some readers find the pacing uneven and the characterization inconsistent, but overall, it's a work of art that leaves a lasting impact.


Quick quotes

    This book is so much more than just Arthur and Camelot.

    White asks difficult questions, usually through Arthur, trying to figure out issues like: Is man inherently good?

    The characters are not much better. Most characterization is flat, and the ones that initially stand out - Arthur/Wart and Lancelot - really become unrecognizable later on, as though written by completely different people.

brilliant 4.50

Musil's wit is compared to Dickens, blending humor with serious commentary. The novel is seen as a profound exploration of human nature and society.

The reviewer draws parallels between Musil's wit and that of Dickens, particularly in Little Dorrit. They appreciate the blend of humor and serious commentary, which adds depth to the narrative. The novel is praised for its profound exploration of human nature and society, making it a thought-provoking read. The reviewer also notes the novel's ability to balance wit with serious themes, creating a rich and engaging experience.


Quick quotes

    Musil's wit reminds me of Dickens whose novel Little Dorrit, in particular, is mixed with witty and serious commentary on the ludicrous nature ...

    The novel is a profound exploration of human nature and society.

    Musil's ability to balance wit with serious themes is commendable.

Appears in Lists