The reviewer enjoyed Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, praising its creative world-building, character development, and suspenseful plot. However, they are critical of the author's personal actions, which they find inexcusable.
The reviewer found Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone to be a highly enjoyable read, particularly appreciating the detailed and imaginative world created by J.K. Rowling. The characters, especially Harry, Ron, and Hermione, are well-developed, and their backstories and personalities are engaging. The plot is suspenseful and effectively introduces the series, making readers eager to continue. The themes of good versus evil and the importance of personal choice are well-executed. However, the reviewer is deeply disappointed by the author's transphobic views, which they find incompatible with the book's positive messages. Despite this, they believe in separating the art from the artist and judge the book on its own merits.
Quick quotes
The visual worlds created in the book are amazing and very well described. It’s hugely creative and the plot is a fantastic introduction to the series.
I like the book but definitely not the author.
Harry is a great central character. He feels lonely and unsure of himself in the world but he begins to grow in confidence when he steps outside his comfort zone and sees what he is capable of achieving.