The reviewer was initially excited and enjoyed parts of the book but found issues with some aspects. The book has a promising premise but some elements did not fully satisfy.
The review expresses a mixed opinion, starting with enthusiasm for the book's concept but later pointing out certain shortcomings that tempered the overall experience. While the story and characters had appeal, some plot or pacing issues detracted from a fully positive impression. This nuanced view suggests the book will appeal to many readers but may not be flawless in execution.
Quick quotes
I was psyched at the idea of this book, enjoyed parts of it, but have issues with some of the rest.
The book has a promising premise.
Some aspects did not fully satisfy.