The reviewer finds the book's rejection of traditional fantasy elements disappointing, as it lacks the wonder, ideals, and heroism typically found in the genre. They criticize the author's attempt to be different for the sake of being different, rather than offering a meaningful alternative.
The reviewer expresses disappointment with the book's departure from traditional fantasy tropes. They argue that while the author aims to be different, this difference is not meaningful or creative. The reviewer criticizes the book for lacking the wonder, ideals, and heroism that are typically found in the genre. They also mention that the book does not offer a compelling alternative to these elements. Overall, the reviewer finds the book's attempt to be different unconvincing and unfulfilling.
Quick quotes
There are plenty of fantasy authors who claim to be doing something different with the genre.
Ironically, they often write the most predictable books of all.
Perhaps it was this abundance of cliche romances that drove Martin to aim for something different.
Unfortunately, you can't just choose to be different, any more than you can choose to be creative.