The Rose Field: The Book of Dust Volume Three

The Rose Field: The Book of Dust Volume Three cover
Good Books rating 2.5
Buy online
Technical
  • ID: 503
  • Added: 2025-09-13
  • Updated: 2025-09-13
  • Formats: 28
  • Reviews: 2
Reviews
reddit.com · Unknown · 2025-09-20
disappointing 1.00

The reviewer found the book to be a miserable indulgence in sad feelings with no plot and bizarre character actions. The writing had some flair but often felt oppressive.

The reviewer struggled through this book, finding it to be a relentless exploration of a character's sad feelings with little to no plot development. The protagonist's actions, such as using cocaine in a portapotty during a threesome, were bizarre and unrelatable. While the writing had moments of flair, it often felt overdone and oppressive. The book is described as a character study or stream of consciousness, focusing heavily on the protagonist's divorce and her misaligned thoughts and actions. Overall, the reviewer was glad to finish the book and did not enjoy the reading experience.


Quick quotes

    I’m so glad this is over.

    There’s no plot, just a lot of miserable indulgence in sad feelings for about 87% of the time.

    One positive I can find is that the writing itself had some flair and flavor, but sometimes that felt oppressive, like when the witty list of things was taking up an entire page.

uk.bookshop.org · Unknown · 2025-09-20
engaging 4.00

The Rose Field: The Book of Dust Volume Three is a captivating conclusion to the trilogy, blending rich storytelling with deep emotional resonance. The characters' journeys are compelling, though some may find the pacing uneven.

The Rose Field: The Book of Dust Volume Three brings a satisfying end to the trilogy, weaving together themes of love, loss, and redemption. The characters' growth and the intricate world-building make it a standout, though the pacing can feel rushed at times. The emotional depth and thought-provoking themes will resonate with fans of the series. While some plot points may feel thin, the overall narrative is engaging and thought-provoking.


Quick quotes

    The characters' journeys are compelling and emotionally resonant.

    The pacing can feel uneven, but the emotional depth makes up for it.

    The world-building is intricate and immersive, making it a standout in the trilogy.

Appears in Lists

Not yet in any lists.