The reviewer initially struggled with Foundryside as it differs from Robert Jackson Bennett's previous Divine Cities trilogy, which they loved for its worldbuilding. However, they eventually fell for the book's heist plot, action-packed sequences, and inventive magic system, despite some clichéd characters and a less distinct setting.
The reviewer had high expectations for Foundryside, given their love for Robert Jackson Bennett's Divine Cities trilogy. Initially, they were disappointed because Foundryside is not a mystery or spy thriller like the Divine Cities books but rather an action-packed heist story. The worldbuilding, which was a highlight in the previous series, felt more like set dressing here. The magic system, called scriving, is inventive and powers neat technology, but it can feel a bit convenient and overpowered at times. The setting, a city reminiscent of Renaissance Venice, lacks detail and feels somewhat indistinct. The characters are somewhat clichéd, although one stands out as unique and adds life to the story. Despite these initial reservations, the reviewer couldn't stop reading, drawn in by the action, magic, and stakes. They acknowledge that others might find these elements more appealing and enjoyable.
Quick quotes
I wasn’t convinced at first. In fact, about halfway through I was… disappointed.
The plot is a heist (well, several), and the worldbuilding seems at first to be set dressing.
The characters are a bit more clichéd here, too.