Killed: Great Journalism Too Hot to Print

Killed: Great Journalism Too Hot to Print cover
Good Books rating 3.43
Technical
  • ID: 4410
  • Added: 2025-10-21
  • Updated: 2025-10-21
  • Reviews: 3
Reviews
Goodreads · Goodreads Community · 2025-10-21
mixed 3.80

The book is highly praised for its collection of remarkable articles that were never published, offering a unique perspective on journalism. However, some readers find the selection and editing uneven.

Many readers appreciate the book for resurrecting remarkable articles that prestigious publications like The New Yorker and the New York Times Magazine chose not to print. The stories behind these articles provide a fascinating look at the editorial process and the challenges faced by journalists. However, some readers feel that the selection of articles is uneven, and the editing could have been more consistent. Overall, it's seen as a valuable collection for those interested in the inner workings of journalism.


Quick quotes

    Killed resurrects remarkable articles that prestigious publications such as The New Yorker, the New York Times Magazine, Harper's, and Rolling Stone...

    The stories behind these articles provide a fascinating look at the editorial process and the challenges faced by journalists.

    Some readers feel that the selection of articles is uneven, and the editing could have been more consistent.

Review of Optometry · 2005-03-15
insightful 3.50

The book is noted for its collection of significant articles that were never published, offering a unique insight into the world of journalism. It's seen as a valuable read for those interested in the media.

This book is highlighted for its collection of significant articles that were never published, providing a unique insight into the world of journalism. The stories behind these articles are particularly engaging, offering a behind-the-scenes look at the editorial decisions that shape what we read. While the book is seen as a valuable resource for those interested in media and journalism, some readers might find the pacing and selection of articles to be uneven. Overall, it's a compelling read that sheds light on the often-hidden aspects of the publishing industry.


Quick quotes

    Killed: Great Journalism Too Hot To Print by David Wallis is a collection of significant articles that were never published.

    The stories behind these articles are particularly engaging, offering a behind-the-scenes look at the editorial decisions that shape what we read.

    While the book is seen as a valuable resource for those interested in media and journalism, some readers might find the pacing and selection of articles to be uneven.

The A.V. Club · 2004-07-06
informative 3.00

The book provides a fascinating look at the behind-the-scenes politics of journalism, but the tabled book reviews are not as compelling as the anecdotes that explain their fate. It's historically useful, but the content can be uneven.

This book offers a unique glimpse into the world of journalism, revealing the stories behind articles that were never published. The anecdotes about why certain pieces were killed are particularly engaging, providing insight into the pressures and politics of the industry. However, the actual reviews and articles included are not always as captivating as the stories about their suppression. It's a valuable historical document, but readers might find the narrative sections more compelling than the content that was originally intended for publication.


Quick quotes

    The tabled book reviews, in particular, are rarely as good as the anecdotes that explain their fate.

    And, though it's historically useful to have these pieces collected in one place, the content can be uneven.

    The stories behind the killed articles are often more interesting than the articles themselves.