The book is highly praised for its collection of remarkable articles that were never published, offering a unique perspective on journalism. However, some readers find the selection and editing uneven.
Many readers appreciate the book for resurrecting remarkable articles that prestigious publications like The New Yorker and the New York Times Magazine chose not to print. The stories behind these articles provide a fascinating look at the editorial process and the challenges faced by journalists. However, some readers feel that the selection of articles is uneven, and the editing could have been more consistent. Overall, it's seen as a valuable collection for those interested in the inner workings of journalism.
Quick quotes
Killed resurrects remarkable articles that prestigious publications such as The New Yorker, the New York Times Magazine, Harper's, and Rolling Stone...
The stories behind these articles provide a fascinating look at the editorial process and the challenges faced by journalists.
Some readers feel that the selection of articles is uneven, and the editing could have been more consistent.