The novel is criticized for being repetitive, overwritten, and contrived, with an overblown narrative that ultimately feels empty despite its ambitious scope.
The reviewer offers a candid and critical perspective on 1Q84, describing it as an overly long and repetitive work that fails to deliver on its ambitious premise. While acknowledging the novel's blend of whimsical romance and magical realism, the review highlights significant flaws in pacing and style, suggesting that the story feels like an 'overblown cocoon filled with nothingness.' This perspective suggests the novel's complexity may not translate into a satisfying reading experience for everyone.
Quick quotes
Unforgivingly contrived, repetitive and overwritten.
1Q84 is like an overblown cocoon filled with nothingness.
A whimsical romance epic with elements of magical realism.