The reviewer struggled with the lack of cohesiveness and rhythm in the collection, noting that while Smith excels at quickly establishing settings, the overall experience feels disjointed.
The reviewer found Zadie Smith's collection challenging due to its lack of cohesiveness and rhythm. They acknowledge Smith's talent for quickly and clearly establishing settings and characters, but feel that the collection as a whole lacks a unifying thread. The reviewer appreciates Smith's ability to capture moments with vivid detail, but ultimately finds the experience frustrating due to the disjointed nature of the stories.
Quick quotes
I struggled with Grand Union. The collection lacked cohesiveness and rhythm.
While Smith is terrific at quickly and clearly establishing a setting or character, the overall collection feels disjointed.
The lack of a unifying theme or thread makes the reading experience frustrating.