The reviewer was captivated by the characters and the promise of poetry but felt the dark side of the story was not fully realized. They wished they could have loved the book more.
The reviewer was drawn to the characters and the poetic elements of the story, which made them want to love the book. However, they found that the darker aspects of the narrative didn't quite come together as they had hoped. The characters were compelling, but the overall execution left them wanting more. The reviewer appreciated the intricacy of the world-building and the unique blend of cultures, but felt that the story could have been more cohesive.
Quick quotes
Drawn by its come-hither characters, its promise of poetry, and by its dark side in the form of a truly nasty character, I really, really wanted to love it.
And yet, despite its many virtues, The Golem and the Jinni didn't quite live up to its promise for me.
The characters are richly drawn and the world-building is impressive, but the story feels a bit disjointed at times.