If the South Had Won the Civil War

by MacKinlay Kantor
If the South Had Won the Civil War cover
Good Books rating 3.5
Historical Fiction
Technical
  • ID: 3501
  • Added: 2025-10-18
  • Updated: 2025-10-18
  • ISBN: 9780312865535
  • Publisher: Macmillan
  • Published: 2001-11-07
  • Reviews: 3

This classic novel, originally published in 1961, delves into a haunting alternate timeline where the South emerges victorious in the Civil War. The story begins with a pivotal moment on May 12, 1863, when General Ulysses S. Grant dies in a tragic accident, setting off a chain of events that reshapes the nation's destiny. With a new introduction by Harry Turtledove and additional essays by the author, this edition offers a compelling exploration of 'what if' scenarios in American history. The book not only presents a gripping narrative but also provides historical context and insights into the creation of the novel. MacKinlay Kantor's meticulous research and masterful storytelling bring to life a world that could have been, offering readers a unique perspective on the Civil War and its aftermath. This edition is a must-read for history enthusiasts and fans of alternate history.

Reviews
LibraryThing · 2025-10-18
informative 3.00

The book is well-written but could have explored more about everyday people's lives. It reads like a real history book.

The reviewer appreciated the book's realistic portrayal of history but felt it lacked depth in exploring the lives of ordinary people. They found the writing style engaging and informative, making it a good read for those interested in alternate history. However, they wished for more personal stories to bring the historical scenario to life.

Quick quotes

    Kantor's book, though good, didn't go far enough into the lives of everyday people.

    It read like a real history book. That was good, but I live in the real ...

    It's a fascinating story of how a slight turn of fate might have changed the destiny of the North, the South and the World.

Emerging Civil War · 2025-10-18
entertaining 4.00

The book is both entertaining and visually engaging with vivid illustrations. It sparks excitement and curiosity about the alternate history.

The reviewer was captivated by the vivid illustrations and the exciting premise of the book. They found the alternate history scenario compelling and enjoyed the way it sparked their imagination. The book's blend of entertainment and historical speculation makes it a delightful read for history enthusiasts.

Quick quotes

    I didn't even have to start reading it; just flipping the pages was exciting, drinking in Robert Fawcett's vivid, full-page pictures of Confederates overrunning ...

    This small volume marks a return to the days when a historian could write with wit and verve.

    It's a fascinating addition to the discussion of alternate history.

Sealion Press · 2021-04-21
thought-provoking 3.50

The book is short and engaging, finished in about an hour and a half. It offers a unique perspective on alternate history.

The reviewer appreciated the brevity of the book, making it a quick and engaging read. They found the alternate history perspective intriguing and thought-provoking, though they noted it could have delved deeper into the lives of everyday people. The book's unique take on history makes it a standout in the genre.

Quick quotes

    The book is short, mercifully so, given how long some alternate history books and series can be.

    I finished it in about an hour and a half in a single sitting.

    It offers a unique perspective on what might have been.

Appears in Lists