The book follows the Wendell family through decades, exploring working-class struggles and tragedies. However, readers found the characters unlikable and the writing style lacking emotional depth, making it hard to connect with the story.
Them by Joyce Carol Oates follows the Wendell family from the 1930s to the 1960s, focusing on their struggles with poverty, crime, and the barriers of working-class life. The book is set against the backdrop of the Detroit race riots, and it delves into themes of love, tragedy, and the horrors that arise from difficult circumstances. While the book is well-written and captures the emptiness and hollowness of the characters' lives, readers found it challenging to connect with the characters or feel moved by their stories. The writing style was described as procedural and lacking in emotional depth, which made it difficult for readers to have a compassionate and deep response. The characters, particularly Loretta, Jules, and Maureen, were seen as unlikable and underdeveloped, which further hindered the emotional impact of the story. Despite the book's exploration of important themes, readers felt that it did not live up to its potential and left them feeling indifferent.
Quick quotes
I want to like her work more than I do. Explorations of independent womanhood, working class barriers and tragedies, academia, etc should all hit me right in the heart- but something about her writing I find a little procedural and lacking in giving ‘heart’ to the characters or story that makes me (who already gets their struggle) have that compassionate and deep response that should be automatic.
I did not feel that the final product, was a masterpiece. I found Jules obsession with Nadine to be realistic enough but I did not find their journey to Texas to be satisfying and the race riots do capture the tension, despair and ultimate destruction, but the hippy professor and the meaningless intellectual arguments which I guess were supposed to be satire didn't do it for me.
I have just one word for these characters — unlikeable. Loretta is an unlikeable daughter who becomes an unlikeable mother to you’ve guessed it unlikeable children.