Guns, Germs, and Steel

by Jared Diamond
Guns, Germs, and Steel cover
Good Books rating 3.67
History
Buy online
Amazon
Format/Price Check
Technical
  • ID: 3133
  • Added: 2025-10-16
  • Updated: 2025-11-27
  • ISBN: 9780393038910
  • Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company
  • Published: 1997-01-01
  • Reviews: 3

In 'Guns, Germs, and Steel,' Jared Diamond presents a compelling argument for why certain societies have dominated others throughout history. By examining the roles of geography, environment, and technology, Diamond dismantles racially based theories and offers a fresh perspective on human development. The book is not only informative but also engaging, making complex ideas accessible to a wide audience. /n/n Diamond's work is supported by extensive research and illustrated with photographs, providing a comprehensive look at the factors that have shaped our modern world. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the broader patterns of human history and the forces that have driven societal progress.

Reviews
Living Anthropologically · 2025-10-16
critical 2.50

They argue that while Diamond's work is interesting, it distorts the historical record and oversimplifies complex issues. They find the book to be a disservice to real historical analysis.

The reviewer from Living Anthropologically acknowledges that Jared Diamond's 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' presents interesting points and has contributed to popular discussions on human history. However, they argue that the book oversimplifies complex issues and distorts the historical record. They criticize Diamond's deterministic approach, which they believe ignores the role of human agency and cultural factors. Overall, they find the book to be a flawed but thought-provoking exploration of human history.

Quick quotes

    Although Diamond makes interesting points, his work from Guns Germs and Steel to Collapse is a distorting disservice to the real historical record.

    Diamond's argument is too deterministic and ignores the role of human agency.

    The book oversimplifies complex issues and presents a skewed view of historical events.

Reddit - Recommended Books · 2021-09-29
thought-provoking 4.50

They find the book long and dense but ultimately rewarding, with a wealth of fascinating facts. They appreciate the theory presented but acknowledge it can be overwhelming at times.

The Reddit user discusses how 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' is a dense and detailed book that can be overwhelming due to the sheer amount of information presented. They find the theory that civilizations were shaped by geographical and environmental factors to be compelling and well-supported. However, they also mention that the book's length and complexity can make it challenging to read at times. Despite this, they find the book to be a valuable and thought-provoking exploration of human history.

Quick quotes

    It’s great. It lays out a theory whereby civilizations were shaped by continental geography and environmental factors.

    The book is long and dense with detail, but written for the lay person.

    I found the plethora of facts exciting and at times bewildering.

The Guardian · 2010-02-18
insightful 4.00

They appreciate Diamond's engaging writing style and the wealth of information presented. They find the book thought-provoking and well-researched, though some arguments may be oversimplified.

The reviewer from The Guardian highlights how Jared Diamond's 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' presents a compelling narrative that challenges conventional views on the development of human societies. They praise Diamond's ability to make complex ideas accessible and engaging for a general audience. However, they also note that some of the arguments might be oversimplified and could benefit from more nuanced discussions on the role of human agency and cultural factors. Overall, they find the book to be a significant contribution to understanding the historical and geographical factors that have shaped civilizations.

Quick quotes

    Diamond's great achievement is to provide a grand, readable narrative of how the modern world came to be and why Europe was the part of the world that did the most to shape it.

    The book is a tour de force of interdisciplinary scholarship, drawing on geography, anthropology, and history.

    While Diamond's arguments are convincing, they are not without their critics, who argue that he underplays the role of individual decision-making and cultural differences.

Appears in Lists