The reviewer finds David Perlmutter's 'Brain Maker' both interesting and surprising, as it challenges conventional theories of disease by emphasizing the role of the gut microbiome in neurological health. While the book's sensational approach undermines its scientific credibility, it succeeds in introducing a neglected subject to a broader audience.
David Perlmutter's 'Brain Maker' presents a compelling argument that the gut microbiome plays a crucial role in neurological health, challenging traditional views on disease. The book suggests that nurturing gut microbes could prevent or treat various neurological conditions, supported by numerous scientific studies. However, Perlmutter's enthusiastic and sensational style, while engaging, detracts from the book's scientific rigor. The reviewer appreciates the book's ability to bring attention to an often-overlooked topic, making it an intriguing introduction for those new to the subject.
Quick quotes
The human microbiome — the universe of especially bacterial organisms that live symbiotically inside of all humans — is housed primarily in the gut, and should be properly considered an “organ system” all to itself.
Perlmutter’s basic argument is that the human microbiome — the universe of especially bacterial organisms that live symbiotically inside of all humans — is housed primarily in the gut, and should be properly considered an “organ system” all to itself.
The effect of this almost unrestrained enthusiasm is to charge the book with energy and excitement, but simultaneously undermines its scientific credibility.