Jonathan Sumption's 'Trial by Battle' is an epic history of the Hundred Years War, covering the first ten years in great detail. While impressive and thorough, it can be overwhelming for general readers due to its length and depth, making it more suitable as a reference work than a cover-to-cover read.
Jonathan Sumption's 'Trial by Battle' is a monumental work that delves deeply into the first ten years of the Hundred Years War. The book is praised for its comprehensive and detailed narrative, providing a thorough account of the conflict's origins and early stages. However, its sheer length and depth can be daunting for casual readers. The reviewer appreciates the extensive context provided, especially the detailed background leading up to the war, which is crucial for understanding the conflict. The book's strength lies in its meticulous recounting of events, making it a valuable resource for scholars and dedicated history enthusiasts. Yet, the reviewer finds the level of detail sometimes overwhelming and the writing not particularly engaging, suggesting it might be better used as a reference work rather than a leisure read. Additionally, the reviewer notes that the book, published in 1990, may not include the latest research and interpretations, which could be a drawback for those seeking the most up-to-date analysis.
Quick quotes
Sumption’s history actually starts in 1328 with the death of Charles IV, King of France.
The depth of background here is stunning and very important if you want to fully understand the Hundred Years War.
The thing that makes Sumption’s book so impressive, and the reason I probably wouldn’t recommend it to people, is the level of detail he captures.