Murder by the Book: A Sensational Chapter in Victorian Crime by

On a quiet Mayfair street in 1840, the brutal murder of Lord William Russell sends shockwaves through London society. The case takes a dramatic turn when the culprit confesses that his actions were inspired by a popular crime novel, sparking a heated debate among prominent writers like Thackeray and Dickens about the influence of literature on behavior. This true crime story delves into the intersection of fiction and reality, exploring how a work of art can be perceived as a catalyst for violence. The narrative raises thought-provoking questions about the responsibilities of authors and the impact of storytelling on society.

Reviews

The Storygraph · 2025-10-13

boring 2.00

They found the book boring and hard to follow, suggesting it might not appeal to all readers. The reviewer's experience highlights the book's potential lack of engagement for some audiences.

The reviewer from The Storygraph expresses a negative opinion, finding the book to be boring and hard to follow. They suggest that while the book might appeal to a specific audience, it is not for everyone. The reviewer's experience highlights the potential lack of engagement and pacing issues that some readers might encounter. This perspective provides a counterpoint to more positive reviews, indicating that the book's appeal may be more niche.

Quick quotes

I'm sure this book is for someone but that someone is most certainly not me.

I found it to be so boring which made it incredibly hard to follow.

The book might appeal to a specific audience, but it is not for everyone.

Literary Review · Miranda Seymour · 2025-10-13

fascinating 4.00

They delve into the historical context and sensationalism surrounding the case, highlighting the author's engaging narrative style. The book is praised for its vivid portrayal of Victorian society and its impact on literature.

Miranda Seymour's review in the Literary Review highlights how the book masterfully recounts a grisly tale while placing it within the broader context of Victorian society. They appreciate the author's ability to weave together historical details and literary analysis, making the book both informative and engaging. Seymour also notes the vivid portrayal of Victorian London, which adds depth to the narrative. They find the book to be a compelling read that sheds light on the intersection of crime, literature, and society during that era.

Quick quotes

Murder by the Book is a fascinating exploration of a sensational crime that captivated Victorian London.

Harman's narrative is both engaging and meticulously researched, providing a vivid portrait of the era.

The book offers a unique perspective on how crime and literature intertwined in the Victorian imagination.

The Times · 2018-10-13

fascinating 4.00

They commend the author for providing a fascinating account of the rise of sensationalism in Victorian literature. The book is noted for its detailed historical context and engaging narrative.

The Times review highlights Claire Harman's ability to recount a grisly tale while providing a rich historical context. They appreciate the book's detailed exploration of the rise of sensationalism in Victorian literature, which adds layers of complexity to the narrative. The review also notes the engaging style in which the story is told, making it a compelling read for those interested in the intersection of crime and literature. The reviewer finds the book to be a well-researched and engaging exploration of a significant historical event.

Quick quotes

Claire Harman recounts this grisly tale with a fascinating account of the rise of sensationalism in Victorian literature.

The book provides a rich historical context that enhances the narrative.

Harman's engaging style makes the story compelling and accessible.

Appears in Lists

Top Ten True Crime Books