The reviewer praises the protagonist Lily for her intelligence, professionalism, and logical approach to solving mysteries, highlighting her as one of their top 10 favorite protagonists. They also appreciate the deep character relationships and the rich world-building, including the complex politics and cultures of the sidhe and werewolves.
The reviewer is highly impressed with the protagonist Lily, emphasizing her intelligence, professionalism, and logical approach to investigations. They appreciate how Lily's character is deeply rooted in her profession as a cop, making her a dedicated and capable investigator. The reviewer also highlights the meaningful and deep relationships between characters, such as Lily's bond with her sister Beth and her fiancé Rule, which are portrayed in a sensible and rational manner. The world-building is praised for its complexity, including the development of different factions and societies, particularly the sidhe and werewolves, which are depicted with unique values and cultures. The reviewer also commends the inclusion of diverse characters and the exploration of magic and its mechanics. However, they note a persistent issue with the all-male lupi, which they find sexist and reduces female presence in the series.
Quick quotes
Lily is a dedicated and capable investigator.
I love the dramatic emotional moments of Beth, the complexities of her dealing with things like killing someone, even in self defence and what that does to someone.
This world building continues not just from cultures and magic and also mechanics.